More on the Dark Money in the Legalization Initiative
September 22, 2020
September 16, 2020
It’s so difficult to talk about the New Approach legalization initiative. The big talking points – “weed for all” and “taxes, taxes!” – throw shade for any number of concerning details. Stans for the initiative like to call those who voice those concerns “greedy,” as though concerns about market structure and corporate structure are not prevailing issues of our times. It is also a strange insult to hurl at those who work in medical marijuana as many will make more money, not less, as a result of the initiative. True, many will be mowed down, too, particularly those who entered the program in the last four years when the era of regulation increased the costs of doing business.
There’s 4.7 million in the legalization initiative. These dollars do not come from the pockets of people whose primary concern is keeping people from going to jail for cannabis. Yet, this is the cause the initiative’s mouthpieces like to spit out whenever a concern about market structure and impact on the medical program is brought up.
We live in the era of gaslighting.
The MTCIA does not have a position on the initiative, but does have concerns about it. There’s millions in dark money in the initiative. The initiative is crafted in such a way that “newcomers” have a year to get licensed to sell medical and then the doors close for a year and only those licensed to sell medical can get licensed to sell in the recreational market for the first year of licensing. This has been misrepresented as giving Montana providers “a head start” when, in fact, it provides a window for others to get in and a secure a head start for themselves.
Maybe we’ll learn soon who the dark money is. When NBC Montana tried to contact the dark money group, the North Fund, which has 2.9 million in the initiative by calling the office listed on their financial forms, the person answering the phone basically said, “never heard of ’em.”
NBCMontana story on the dark money here.
Implementation Timeline II: Personal use and cultivation
September 1, 2020
The legalization initiative in Montana requires the Department of Revenue to have applications available for licenses to sell cannabis to the adult use/recreational market as of October 2021. Licensing is called for by January 2022. In other words, legal recreational sales would begin in January 2022 if implementation goes as laid out in the initiative.
The implementation date for the personal use provision occurs sooner, shortly after the initiative passes, in January 2021.
As of January 2021, any adult in possession of an ounce or less of cannabis, even without a medical card, is okay under the law. This makes sense in that it would be wrong to prosecute people for something the citizens have determined should not be a crime. Further, under an adult use law, the right to grow for oneself should absolutely be protected. That said, it nonetheless creates impacts on the cannabis market. “Cannabis market” here meant in the broadest terms, not just the licensed, regulated market.
In terms of supply and demand, if the legalization initiative passes, as of January 2021:
Demand, which includes any adult in Montana who wishes to obtain and consume cannabis, is acting within the law as long as the possessed, purchased, or obtained cannabis does not exceed an ounce.
Supply, in the section of the law covering personal use (Sec. 8), does not refer to a licensed cannabis business (medical or otherwise). If refers to private citizens and their ability to “transfer” or “distribute” cannabis and cannabis products without threat of prosecution. (Cannabis “products” are included as processing and manufacturing is allowable.)
Some bullets on this:
- Adults are no longer at risk of bringing an ounce or less of cannabis into the state. Thus, cannabis can legally enter the state at the level of personal possession. For example, an individual from Washington can legally bring cannabis purchased in Washington into Montana. Also, a Montanan who has visited another state can bring up to an ounce back into the state. Of course, if a person crosses a zero-tolerance state, such as Idaho, that person is taking a risk while in that state.
- Adults purchasing on the black market in Montana are no longer at risk of prosecution. The supply in this case is a black market distributor exchanging cannabis for cash. So, the supply side in this example would be breaking the law, but not the demand side of the transaction.
- Adults without medical cards cultivating their own cannabis within allowable limits are no longer at risk of prosecution for cultivating, possessing, or transferring, manufacturing, processing or distributing that cannabis to others. These “transfer” or “distributions” would not be the “black market,” so much as the “unregulated market.” Cannabis grown for “personal use” cannot legally be “sold.” However, money in exchange for something else or some other service that comes with a “gift” of cannabis is not prohibited and based on the past behavior of the Montana cannabis market, is predictable.
If the above activities are carried out but the amount of cannabis involved is over the allowable one ounce, but less than two ounces, there are graduated penalties with the 3rd offense topping out with a penalty of $500 or 8 hours of community service.
A dynamic this provides for is that a provider licensed in the medical marijuana program cannot sell to an adult without a medical card. However, as an individual, that provider can provide a free ounce to any adult with the purchase of, say, cannabis consulting; or perhaps a person can become a member of a club of some sort and with that membership comes, as an example, an ounce per month. Or, perhaps there are different levels of membership providing for different perks. Thus, the cannabis is being distributed but not, strictly speaking, “sold.”
Of course, technically, that cannabis cannot come from cannabis grown or manufactured in the medical program. Theoretically, the cannabis in the medical program is tracked. It would have to come from a private garden of no more than 4 plants per person or 8 per household. So, if a household has 8 plants producing 2.5 oz/ plant every 3 mos, that amounts to 20 oz every 3 months, or 100 oz/yr. If each of those individuals is consuming 2 oz/mos, that’s 14 oz available to distribute every three months or 56 oz/yr (3.5 lbs). Of course, that cannabis may also be processed or used to manufacture other cannabis goods.
The law does not include any allowance or prohibitions on processing or manufacturing by one person for another. However, the “check” on this, statutorily, might be that any cannabis produced by a home grower in excess of 1 oz must be kept in a locked space in or on the grounds of one private residence.
However, a person can give “the manufacturer” the cannabis (“transfer”).
It is unclear that “the manufacturer” can then be in possession of that cannabis in order to process it.
“The manufacturer” may then return the processed cannabis to the party from which it originated.
Once providers are licensed to sell to the adult use market, straight forward purchases from dispensaries become available. However, these other allowances do continue.
As said, it makes sense that the criminalization of marijuana should be discontinued if the citizens decide to legalize and penalties should not continue until formal licensing is instituted. The above is provided not as an argument for or against anything but as an analysis and a focus on some of the market dynamics.
- There will likely be small unregulated networks of adult use distribution (different from black market) and these exchanges would constitute a portion of the adult use market that would not be taxed and thus not factor into revenue estimates.
- It may be a consideration to limit home processing or manufacturing to solvent-free methods in the interest of public health and safety.
NEW SECTION. Section 8. Personal use and cultivation of marijuana — penalties. (1) Subject to the limitations in [section 16], the following acts are lawful and shall not be an offense under state law or the laws of any local government within the state or be a basis to impose a civil fine, penalty, or sanction, or be a basis to detain, search, or arrest, or otherwise deny any right or privilege, or to seize or forfeit assets under state law or the laws of any local government for a person who is 21 years of age or older:
(a) possessing, purchasing, obtaining, using, ingesting, inhaling, or transporting 1 ounce or less of marijuana, except that not more than 8 grams may be in a concentrated form;
(b) transferring, delivering, or distributing without consideration, to a person who is 21 years of age or older, 1 ounce or less of marijuana, except that not more than 8 grams may be in a concentrated form;
(c) in or on the grounds of a private residence, possessing, planting, or cultivating up to four mature marijuana plants and four seedlings and possessing, harvesting, drying, processing, or manufacturing the marijuana
What We Want for Our Customers
August 31, 2020
The MTCIA has members that support the legalization initiative in Montana. We have members tentative about its impact on the medical program. We have members concerned it’s not the right law at the right time.
There is nobody in Montana’s cannabis marketplace who wants to see people jailed for cannabis use. That doesn’t mean there’s not other provisions worth discussing. Not taking a position on the initiative allows the MTCIA to examine it the way those involved in the market need to, whether business owner or customer. What we aim at when we discuss the initiative is nuts and bolts analysis.
For Montana’s cannabis customers we want:
Therefore, when we look at the law we ask those questions. Does it promote these qualities in the market?
As we may now and then post or comment on the initiative, we wanted you to know where we were coming from.
Legalization on the Ballot: I-190 Timeline
August 17, 2020
Timeline for implementation of I-190
The entire recreational law will go into effect Oct. 1, 2021. Department rules must be completed at that time and the department may begin to receive license applications. For the first 12 months, only those currently holding licenses to provide medical cannabis will be considered. The department must accept applications for licensure and endorsement on or before January 1, 2022.
Several sections go into effect in January of 2021. These are:
- Section 16 creating limitations on rec use, such as possession on school grounds, operating a vehicle
- Sction: 8 Personal use and cultivation permitted.
- Section 23 Confiscated cannabis and paraphernalia must be returned if a person is in compliance with the law (in other words, no forfeiture)
- Section 40 – 49 change MCA consequences (current law) for possession
May 28, 2020
Cardholders Will Be Untethered June 2, 2020.
Since the beginning of the medical marijuana program in 2004, medical marijuana cardholders have been required to identify on their paperwork with the state who they would purchase their medical cannabis from.
In SB 265 during the 2019 legislative session, a provision was passed to allow cardholders to purchase from any licensed medical marijuana provider in Montana. This provision will go into effect June 2, 2020. The MTCIA supported this provision and recognizes the need for cardholders to be able to freely sort the market for quality and service and products that meet their individual needs.
Many cardholders who have had only one or two providers over any significant amount of time will learn the range of quality that is available and discover the combination of products from different sources that best serve them. Members of the MTCIA actively advocated for and successfully forwarded policy to create a competitive market, driven by safety, quality and service. Untethering is the critical step in making the customer the leader in determining the make-up of the medical cannabis market in Montana.
The ability of the customer to “find” providers is seriously curtailed by the state’s advertising ban. Visibility and word of mouth will become significant determinants of a providers’ ability to compete. Learn more about untethering by visiting one of our members.
See coverage in the Missoulian on the upcoming untethering here.
A 420 Greeting During the COVID-19 Pandemic
April 20, 2020
April 20, “420,” has been a day of celebration and recognition of marijuana for nearly 50 years. On 420 in 2020, the cannabis industry faces challenges as do all industries in these times of COVID19. Medical marijuana in Montana has been deemed an essential service. Cardholders purchase more per visit in the aim of leaving their homes as seldomly as possible. Sheltering-in-place creates stress which often escalates health conditions which results in an increase in consumption.
Dispensaries are accepting orders and offering curbside service. They are taking increased sanitation precautions and adhering by social distancing guidelines. Though medical marijuana sales in MT did spike with the pandemic, they are leveling and expected to dip if the crisis continues and people remain out of work.
Like other businesses, medical marijuana providers are impacted by supply shortages. Gloves, face masks, cleaning supplies. Staples like sugar and flour for edibles have at times been unavailable at markets. Supply lines for packaging stumble. The workforce faces challenges, too. Some workers choose to stay home to reduce risks to vulnerable family members. With schools closed, some face childcare issues. Though not eligible for federal assistance, many providers continue to pay workers who must quarantine or face other obstacles to work attendance.
This 420 2020, we are in this together. The MTCIA aims to make this a safe holiday as we serve with safety and dignity those in Montana who benefit from the therapeutic use of medical marijuana.